
The Minister for Education Mary Hanafin needs to explain why she has failed to make any provision for Dublin 15 in her announcement of a €555 million spend on education projects.
"Despite a huge demand for a second level school in Castaheany to serve the new areas at Littlepace and Ongar, the Minister has failed so far to either acquire the site or indeed to include the building of the school in her new plans.
The new program provides for 23 new post-primary schools and 4 new primary schools. It’s difficult to know why Dublin 15 has been left out, in light of the fact that more recent developments in Adamstown in Lucan, Donabate and Balbriggan have been included"
Deputy Joan Burton raised the issue of the permanent school for the Castaheany Educate Together School and for the second level school on the first day of the new Dail session,
The Minister’s reply is virtually unchanged from six months ago, stating that she is still trying to acquire the permanent building sites.
No provision has been made either for additional second level places or indeed primary school places in the Castleknock area. Castleknock Community College is now bursting at the seams and has no P.E. hall despite the Minister’s promises. As with the Clonee area huge housing developments continue to take place in the Castleknock area, including the Phoenix Park Racecourse with 2300 units and Pelletstown in nearby Ashtown with 4500 new units.
No provision has been made for a secondary school for either of these extraordinarily large developments. It seems that Dublin 15 must once more wait at the bottom of this government’s queue for essential school facilities.
Chun an Aire Oideachais agus Eolaíoctha
To the Minister for Education and Science
To ask the Minister for Education and Science if her Department has acquired a
permanent site for a school (details supplied) in Dublin 15; the cost of the
site; the amount of land which has been acquired; when the building of the
permanent school will commence; the estimated value of the contract; the
estimated completion date; and if she will make a statement on the matter.
- Joan Burton.
* For WRITTEN answer on Wednesday, 28th September, 2005.
Reference Number: 25860/05
Freagra
Minister for Education and Science (Mary Hanafin, T.D.)
Negotiations regarding the acquisition of a site to cater for the permanent accommodation needs of the school to which the Deputy refers are at an advanced stage. Given the Band 1 status attaching to this project under the prioritisation criteria for large scale building projects, it will proceed to architectural planning as soon as possible following site acquisition.
Due to the commercial sensitivities attaching to site acquisitions generally, the information requested by the Deputy relating to site cost is not available for release at present. My Department's policy in relation to all site acquisitions is to treat them with the strictest confidentiality until the acquisition has been completed. This is to ensure that my Department will achieve the best value for money option. It is a further policy of my Department not to publish estimated building contract costs to avoid prejudicing the tendering process.
The amount of land to be acquired will allow for the development of school facilities to meet the needs of the school concerned along with shared community facilities which will be developed in conjunction with Fingal County Council. This cooperation ensures that the delivery of school and community facilities maximises the use of available land and avoids the duplication of facilities such as sports facilities, playing pitches etc.
Chun an Aire Oideachais agus Eolaíoctha
To the Minister for Education and Science
To ask the Minister for Education and Science her proposals to provide a second level school in the Littlepace and Castaheany area of Clonee, Dublin 15, in view of the thousands of new homes in the area; the progress which has been made in acquiring the reserved site in the area for the second level school;when the new school will be given sanction; when she proposes to permit the new school to proceed to contract and to open; and the estimated cost of the site and of the contract for building and fitting the school.
- Joan Burton.
* For WRITTEN answer on Wednesday, 28th September, 2005.
Reference Number: 25861/05
Freagra
Minister for Education and Science (Mary Hanafin, T.D.)
As the Deputy will be aware, my Department is planning the development of a new post primary school in Dublin 15 to serve the growing population of that area.
It is intended to progress the provision of the school in Phibblestown area as a Design Build Project. My Department has advertised in the Official Journal of the European Union for design build teams. The short-listing of these teams is currently being undertaken. A project manager has also been appointed to manage the delivery of this project.
It is not possible to say at this early stage when the new school will open,however, the acquisition process for the site is at an advanced stage. Due to the commercial sensitivities attaching to site acquisitions generally, the information requested by the Deputy relating to site cost is not available for release at present.
My Department's policy in relation to all site acquisitions is to treat them with the strictest confidentiality until the acquisition has been completed. This is to ensure that my Department will achieve the best value for money option. In the same way, my Department does not publish estimated contract sums to avoid prejudicing the tendering process.
Has The Plug Been Pulled On The Abbotstown Campus?
Press Statement from Joan Burton T.D
Urgent Need to Assess Minister Harney’s Tax Breaks for Private Hospitals Initiative
22nd September 2005
Deputy Joan Burton has expressed her concern over the decision made by Minister for Health Mary Harney to make tax based investment in health services the major plank of government policy in providing additional hospital and care facilities.
"I have no doubt that such tax breaked investment will be hugely popular with investors. However, it is not clear if any detailed work has been carried out on the implications for health service provision, targeting of healthcare provision to needs or the regional implications.
No estimates have been provided of the cost of such tax expenditures to tax payers as compared with the benefits generated by new private hospitals, nor whether admissions to such hospitals will be based on medical need or on ability to pay.
I have written to the chairman of the Finance and Public Services Committee Mr. Sean Fleming calling for a detailed assessment of Minister Harney’s proposals.
I have proposed that the committee invite the Tanaiste and Minister for Health Mary Harney T.D. and the Minister for Finance Brian Cowen T.D. come before the committee and explain in detail the policy and its ramifications for the health services. The committee should also have an opportunity to hear from a number of experts in health service economics, such as Dr Maev-Ann Wren, the country’s leading expert on healthcare economics.
It may also be appropriate to hear from a representative from the existing voluntary/private hospitals sector sector such as Dr. James Sheehan, one of the founding members of the Blackrock Clinic, on the long-term requirements for private hospital investors and the implications for patients and users of the health care services.
The recent investigations into the Leas Cross nursing home show that very important public policy issues arise when the provision of facilities appears to be driven by tax breaks rather the quality of care.
Ireland has long had a mixed provision between public and private/voluntary provision. Traditionally much of the private/voluntary sector has been run on a ‘not for profit’ basis.
The Tanaiste’s recent proposals would appear to indicate a sea change in policy with profound economic implications for the health service and for the general tax paying public.
It is high time that Minister Harney explained the nature of her plans to the Finance committee and more importantly, to the general public who stand to be greatly affected by such an attempted profound change in the Irish healthcare system."
OECD Report Shows Chronic Government Under-Spending on Education
Press Statement by Deputy Joan Burton T.D.
15th September 2005
A report produced by the international Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD) shows the extent of this government’s underfunding of our schools. Shockingly, spending on primary and second-level education in Ireland increased at only half the rate of economic growth in the Celtic Tiger era.
Deputy Burton said of the report:
“These figures prove the point that I have been trying to make to this government about the schools in Dublin 15. Throughout the last Dail term I constantly brought up the issue of the lack of facilities at St. Brigid’s School Castleknock and Castleknock Community College.
On top of these problems, schools such as Mary Mother of Hope, Littlepace NS and St. Patrick’s NS, Diswellstown found themselves completely overwhelmed by the number of applicants for places. Also, the Castaheany Educate Together School has still been forced to operate from a temporary site due to the chronic lack of funding it receives.
This government has not invested enough money in our education system – and this report by a respected international organisation brings shame upon our FF/PD government.”
An Post Admits To Problems In Postal Service for Dublin 15
In response to a query from Joan Burton T.D., An Post have admitted to delays in the delivery of mail in the Dublin 15 area. An Post has claimed that delays in the delivery of mail have occurred because of abseenteism due to sick leave. However, the main problem is seen to stem from the dispute between An Post management and the main union representing An Post workers. As a result of the dispute over new working methods, An Post has not recruited sufficient new employees to provide an efficient postal system.
Deputy Burton stated:
"I have been contacted by numerous constituents concerning the delays they have experienced in receiving their mail. It is incumbent upon An Post to sort out its dispute with its workers and gets its service working well again. Unfortunately the dispute seems to be dragging on.
This situation is completely unacceptable and cannot continue. An Post are obliged under the Universal Service Obligation to ensure that every home and premises receives a postal delivery each working day. With the company back in profit from last year the priority must be to ensure proper staffing measures are in place to ensure that the USO is fully carried out."
If you have any queries on these or any other issues please contact my office by reply or at 6184006.